Barking up the wrong tree

Resident upset with changes to dog access at Marshall Field


‘m appalled that recently our Vernon mayor and council, except Scott Anderson, voted to make the popular Marshall Field dog walk area on-leash only. Apparently, this is a solution looking for a problem. City staff were reported to have two reasons for recommending a change from off-leash to on-leash.

One is protection of the endangered spadefoot toad habitat, for which the city, in respect of a provincial Ministry of Environment agreement, has built or enhanced the ponds along the southern portion of Marshall Field.

I’m told most of the toads are in these ponds, and ponds on the old Lakers Golf Course, with much fewer in the creek, where some of our dogs like to cool off and play.

Of the kilometre or so of creek through Marshall Field, there are only a handful of spots, a small fraction of this distance, where dogs typically access the creek.

I appreciate that preservation of habitat for toads, and other creatures, means we should limit our impact upon these riparian areas to preserve connectivity. But does that have to mean no access to the water for our dogs? I think not.

City staff and council could easily find a more refined solution than a blanket loss of off-leash exercise for our dogs. How about no dogs within five metres of the ponds, and access to the creek restricted to two or three defined points?

The second reason given for going on-leash only is to reduce the number of dogs, and their droppings, on the playing fields, and to minimize confrontations between dogs, or dogs and people.

I understand the frustration with this issue, as I see a minority of dog-walkers and soccer parents continue to walk their pets across the soccer pitches. I agree this has to stop.

Will leashes stop dogs from going on the playing fields, or reduce confrontations? No!

The solution has nothing to do with leashes. It has everything to do with where owners choose to take their dogs, and how they control them, whether they’re regular dog-walkers or soccer parents. The onus should be on owners to guide and control their pets responsibly, using a leash if needed. I have no problem with fines for owners with dogs on the playing fields.

Councillor Cunningham was correct in pointing out there are other off-leash dog parks in the city, but Marshall Field is one of only two good ones with water access. The other is BX Ranch Park. The loss of one of Vernon’s best off-leash dog parks, without compelling reasons, or any effort to collaborate with users, is unacceptable.

On the issue of dogs at Marshall Field, Vernon council has failed to clearly define the problem, and to find solutions that are effective, supported by users, enforceable, and without significant negative consequences.

Where there are real problems with dogs, real solutions are available. Simply requiring all dogs to be on-leash is not a solution. It’s a call to arms.

Colin Heggie



Just Posted

Monty Python’s Spamalot set for Vernon stage

Big Apple Productions raises silliness to an art form

Vernon RCMP ready to arrest, for kids

Suspects sought for North Okanagan Jail & Bail Thursday, May 30

More classrooms on the way for Vernon students

Minister of Education announces 240-seat expansion at BX Elementary

Grammatically incorrect tagging strikes Vernon bylaw office

Anti-tag team will begin working next week to target such vandalism

Brain Injury Awareness Month brings discussion to Vernon

The Vernon Brain Health Symposium takes place June 1

Rally for climate justice strikes Vernon yet again

A handful of students were seen rallying in front of the Okanagan Science Centre

Sit-in on Saturday will protest move to curb loitering in Penticton’s downtown

Nanaimo Square Sit-In is taking place from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Friend of accused Kelowna murderer takes the stand

Elrich Dyck’s testimony continued Friday with details from the night Chris Ausman was killed

Crews respond to smoke at Penticton thrift store

The rooftop A/C unit began filling the building with smoke, prompting them to evacuate

Housing provided for women and children fleeing violence in Penticton

Announcement on Friday is part of a provincewide initiative to construct additional housing.

People’s Party of Canada leader talks B.C. trade to Penticton supporters

Maxime Bernier, head of the new federal political party, spoke at Time Winery on Friday

Princeton RCMP recover stolen homework and save the grade

It’s a slightly better excuse than “the dog ate my homework.” Earlier… Continue reading

New Summerland distillery has received recognition

Alchemist Distiller won audience choice award at recent competition

Scheer says it would take Conservatives five years to balance budget

Scheeraccused the Liberal government of spending $79.5 billion of previously unbudgeted funds

Most Read