Letter: Fletcher’s grab-bag column

Information that works mostly on cherry picking, innuendo, and lack of context.

Tom Fletcher’s recent New Year’s rant on “Climate: for 2019, wishful thinking replaces evidence” (Morning Star, Jan. 2, 2019) includes a grab bag of information that works mostly on cherry picking, innuendo, and lack of context.

Three examples highlight this, comments on the Congo, the 2008 global recessions, and a comparison to China.

First, the Congo: Fletcher indicates that the Congo is “noted mostly for corruption, civil war and lawless mining.” No context is provided. The Belgian Congo as it was formerly known was a privately held colony of the Belgian King Leopold established in 1885. At the time it was brutalized as were many European colonies for resource extraction. After independence in 1960 the democratically elected leader, Patrice Lumumba, was assassinated in a U.S. CIA inspired plot. Since then the Congo has been served by corrupt officials subject to World Bank and International Monetary Funds “structural adjustment programs”, commonly known as austerity, leading to more European/western resource extraction. The “lawless mining” is due in large part to Canadian mining companies operating in the region, using warlords and corrupt officials to enable their setup and mineral extraction – the civil war has much to do with this, using both mercenaries and outside armies to keep the resource extraction going.

Next, China: apparently Canada’s carbon output is such that “annual emissions…amount to a few days worth of China’s output.” However, China has 40 times Canada’s population, while Canada has twice the per capita carbon output (World Bank, 2014). China’s economy has recently raised over 600 million people out of poverty based on the World Bank’s definition of poverty as being US$1.25 per day. As China’s economy stabilizes, and as China is currently a world leader in searching for ‘green’ energy and environmental systems, it will continue to better Canada on a per capita basis. As for the “few days”, it calculates to being about 24 days, varying according to a source. In other words, individual Canadians should feel no pride in Fletcher’s out of context, cherry picked, and incorrect Chinese statistic.

Finally though, Fletcher – rather than simply dumping out a bunch of out of context information – actually hints at the solution to global warming when he says “The only time they [emissions] dipped was in a deep worldwide recession that began in late 2008.” During a recession, there is much less spending, much less consumerism, less travel, less transportation of goods, fewer air miles. It is an indictment of our society’s desire for more stuff, more growth, more energy consumption.

The real solution to global warming – and all environmental problems – will only come when society as a whole is willing to adopt a more minimalistic lifestyle using far less carbon-based energy and eliminates the corporate mantra of consumerism and continual growth. On that basis, I do not see much hope for controlling our carbon output as most people are unwilling to change their corporate created desires for more stuff.

Jim Miles

Just Posted

Service with a smile: How inclusive workplaces benefit everyone

Vernon employee serves up service with a smile

North Okanagan residential market runs true to form

Market picking up as expected, OMREB says

Fundraising campaign launched for man caught in SilverStar avalanche

In only two days, the GoFundMe surpassed its $15,000 goal

Business is booming in Lumby: Chamber

Chamber looks to capture history

A tough hill to climb: Armstrong business owner overcomes odds

Armstrong biologist-businesswoman celebrates a milestone anniversary

Sparks fly as SUV speeds down wrong side of Highway 1 trying to flee RCMP

Captured on video, the vehicle headed westbound against oncoming traffic before crashing

Bobrovsky perfect as Blue Jackets blank Canucks 5-0

Vancouver shut out for 10th time this season

Kelowna artist featured on furniture

Shandra Smith’s work is now available on credenzas

Destructive blaze in West Kelowna fatal for cat

The fire at a West Kelowna condo claimed the life of one tenant’s cat

Sock Hop aims to send dancers back to another time

Writers’ Festival fundraiser in Salmon Arm springs into step for another year

Man pinned under metal tank in West Kelowna

Emergency personnel are on the scene

WWE, WCW elite hits Vernon mat for professional wrestling show

International wrestlers descend upon Vernon for Canadian Wrestling’s Elite anniversary tour

Terror at sea: Helicopter rescues frightened cruise passengers in Norway

The Viking Sky cruise ship was carrying 1,300 passengers and crew when it experienced engine trouble

DOJ: Trump campaign did not co-ordinate with Russia in 2016

Attorney General William Barr said special counsel “does not exonerate” Trump of obstructing justice

Most Read